In this Schwinn 230 vs Schwinn 270 compare and contrast post they are put up against each other to explain how these two recumbent exercise bikes differ to help to answer the big question as to whether the difference in price is really justified.
At first look these bikes look remarkably similar. Which is to be expected as they made by the same company and do have many of the same parts.
The only obvious differences when you look and compare them at first is the price and the seat – with the Schwinn 270 being more and its seat being padded.
But there are some other differences to think about with the Schwinn 270 with the console having more functionality.
Both bikes get high ratings from customers on the whole – the overall score is very similar which can make it difficult to choose between the two.
Before getting into just how they differ here is a quick overview of these 2 recumbent exercise bike:
Schwinn 230 Recumbent Bike
It has quiet magnetic resistance with 20 marked levels and a perimeter weight flywheel to provide a smooth pedaling experience reducing impact on the joints.
The console allows you to play your music and movies through 2 speakers, there is a 3 speed fan to help keep you cool. a media shelf for your electronics and water bottle holder.
It has 22 different workout programs including a quick start program and one you can set for yourself to provide plenty of variety for your exercising.
It can be adjusted for a range of heights between 4ft 11 and 6 ft 3 ins. The seat is reasonably comfortable and along with the backrest it provides good support for the back.
Schwinn 270 Recumbent Bike
The padded oversized seat and backrest provide a comfortable riding position and support your back.
It has 25 magnetic resistance levels that go up in small increments. The riding motion is fluid with little impact making it gentle on the joints.
It comes with all the same accessories as the 230.
The bike has a total of 29 different workout programs that can be set and to be used by people of all abilities. You can also to set your own workouts.
It can accommodate 4 different user profiles to track and monitor progress individually.
It’s a quiet bike so can be used while watching TV or even when others are sleeping as it won’t disturb them. The loudest noise is likely to be your breathing
The Differences – The Facts And Explanation
Here are the important differences between these 2 recumbent exercise bikes
Workout Programs. The Scnwinn 270 has 7 more programs for a total of 29. It has 3 more profile programs (pre-programmed workouts), a customizable heart rate % program, a recovery test (how quick you recover from a workout) and 2 additional user defined workout (you set these up yourself – there 1 per user).
Resistance Levels. The Schwinn 270 has 25 resistance levels which is 5 more than the Schwinn 230. It doesn’t give you any more overall resistance it just goes up/down in smaller increments.
Heart Rate Monitor. The Schwinn 270 as well as hand pulse sensors is compatible with uncoded Polar heart rate straps (needs to be bought separately). The Schwinn 230’s heart rate monitoring only works with the hand pulse sensors.
Hand pulse sensors have a tendency not to be accurate or provide a consistent reading of your heart rate. This makes it difficult to use for staying within heart rate zones or using the heart rate programs. This is something common with all bikes that have these sensors.
Some people do get them to work satisfactorily but many struggle.
Seat. The Schwinn 270 has a padded seat that makes it a little more comfortable than the plastic molded seat of the Schwinn 230. It isn’t made of breathable material and can get a little hot compared to the Schwinn 230 that has holes that allow air to circulate.
User Profiles. The Schwinn 270 gives you up to 4 user profiles you can customize for each user whereas the 230 has a maximum of 2. These help with monitoring, analyzing and storing your workouts by individual. These are the only profiles available – if you have a guest user they will be assigned to the last user profile that was used and their workout added to that user unless you change it.
Cranks. The Schwinn 270 has a 3 piece crank and the Schwinn 230 has one piece crank.
As you’d expect from the name the 3 piece crank is 3 pieces – 2 crank arms (the arms that hold the pedals) and a spindle, whereas 1 piece it is all made as one piece.
A 3 piece crank is usually stronger and can take more pedaling for longer periods. Having noted that, to date there hasn’t been any difference in customer experience as to one lasting longer than the other. The only time it make a difference is if you are using the bike at the top resistance levels for extended periods and then you’d expect the Schwinn 270 crank to outlast the Schwinn 230 (but there have not been any reported problems with the cranks that I’ve come across).
Pedal Thread. If you are thinking on changing the pedals then the Schwinn 270 thread is 9/16 ins and the Schwinn 230 is 1/2 in thread.
Pedals. The Schwinn 270 pedals are oversized giving more surface area to grip and accommodating larger shoe size than the Schwinn 230 standard size pedals.
Bike Weight. The Schwinn 270 is 5 lbs heavier at 86.6 lbs. Both bikes have transport wheels which hold most of the weight making it much easier to move the bike around.
What About The Price
When I checked the Schwinn 230 was just over $105 cheaper than the Schwinn 270.
Which One Should I Buy?
These are both very good bikes to get low impact exercise. For me the 3 differences that make the most difference are the seat, the heart rate monitoring and the user profiles.
If there are more than 2 of you using bike and you want to track your workouts and progress then the Schwinn 270 is the better option. It does also come with the better seat and the option to use the more accurate heart rate strap for monitoring heart rate and training in your most effective heart rate zone. It also has more workout programs to give variety to your workouts.
The other reason to choose the Schwinn 270 is if you want to be using your heart rate zones for optimum training for you age and fitness levels. You do need to buy the heart rate strap separately but this gives you a more accurate and consistent reading than the hand pulse sensors (this is common with all bikes). You could do this (use a heart rate strap) with the Schwinn 230 but you’d need to monitor your heart rate separately to your workout.
Side By Side Comparison
The table below shows the Schwinn 230 and 270 features, specifications and dimensions next to each other line by line. It helps to give a full picture of the two but as you’d expect many of the categories compared the bikes are the same.
|Feature||Schwinn 230||Schwinn 270|
|Weighted Flywheel||13 lbs||13 lbs|
|Bike Weight||81.6 lbs||86.6 lbs|
|Max User Weight||300 lbs||300 lbs|
|Min User Height||4 ft 11 ins||4 ft 11 ins|
|Max User Height||6ft 3 ins||6 ft 3 ins|
|Use Dimensions||Height 50 ins|
Width 28 ins
Length 64 ins
|Height 50 ins
Width 27 ins
Length 64 ins
|Accessories||Water bottle holder|
3 speed fan
|Water bottle holder
3 speed fan
|Heart Rate Sensors||Yes||Yes|
|Crank||1 piece||3 piece|
|Heart Rate Sensor Type||Hand Pulse||Hand Pulse
I hope you know have the information you needed to be able to make a decision between the two as to which is the right one for you. It would be great to know what your thoughts are about the bikes.
Filed under: Recumbent Exercise Bike Guides
Like this post? Subscribe to my RSS feed and get loads more!