It is a strange term q factor. It sounds more like it should be a name for a game or panel show about science or mathematics not something to do with pedals and bikes – indoor or outdoor.
I’m not sure why it is called the Q factor but it is simply the horizontal distance between the inside of the left and right pedals where they attach to the crank – you read more here http://sheldonbrown.com/cranks.html. It is felt that narrower Q factor is the more natural for your riding, the more efficient it is and results in less knee injury as it is closer to how you would walk. But there is discussion and debate on how narrow you need it and some of it comes down to personal preference, leg length and hip width – so it will be different for each person.
The general rule seems to be the narrower the better but it can sometime be too narrow and cause knee injury because of twisting of the knee but this is more discussed with outdoor bikes due in part to the way they are made. (See http://www.kneesaver.net/ for more information).
The Q factor for spin bikes tends to be wider than that for outdoor bikes as they need to accommodate the wider frame, the drive guard and the housing.
There is a wide range of Q factors for spin bikes even at the more expensive end with some of these bikes having a wide Q factor.
An interesting thing about this is that not all manufacturers appear to think it is important enough to let you know what it is for their bikes by displaying it in the description on their site or on e-commerce sites. in fact when I asked them by email some of them responded their bikes didn’t have them or they didn’t know it! Not a great attitude to their products and their potential customers concerns.
Anyway moving on.
One of the most popular and highly rated spin bikes is the Keiser M3 plus. It is a great looking bike and it can be seen in many different gyms and clubs around the country as well as in the homes of people who take their spinning and training very seriously. It is a quality bike. It’s Q factor is 7 3/4 inches which is wider than some more affordable bikes like the Sunny Health and fitness Pro Indoor Cycle with a Q factor of 7 1/2 inches.
The Keiser has a lot of great features but the Q factor width is where it does not come up to scratch and some people may not like this especially those wanting to use for indoor training when they can’t get outside on their bike.
If you are used to riding outdoor bikes you might find riding the bike initially a bit like you have legs around a table to get your feet wide enough. Well that is an exaggeration but you may find it uncomfortable to begin with at least. (I write more about how Keiser M3 Plus compares with the Spinner NXT (a bike with a narrow Q factor) in my comparison post). The width is to accommodate the magnetic resistance and the drive housing as mentioned earlier.
Another bike that is narrower and but more mid-price range is the Schwinn AC Sport with a Q factor 6 11/16 – it does come with manual resistance which seems take up less room giving you the narrower distance but is a highly regarded bike.
The company that seems to take this most seriously is Spinner and they are the original spin bike manufacturers. They started the idea of making indoor cycles to give a similar riding experience to outdoor bikes.
They have worked on narrowing the width of the Q factor for their bikes to improve that experience again. The 2 Spinner bikes I’ve reviewed so far do have the narrowest Q factor of the bikes I’ve reviewed for this site. The Q factors are: for the Spinner Sport (priced below $400) is 6 7/64 inches and Spinner NXT is 6 7/32 inches (priced over $1000).
For many people using a spin bike the Q factor is may not be a huge factor in getting the bike to fit them properly to avoid injury and increase performance. But this depends on how often and how long they are using the bike and what their fitness goals are.
If you are using athletic shoes and sliding them into toe cages it is not likely to be that major a consideration but if you have specialist shoes with cleats for getting foot position optimized you are going to want to get best fit for you.
Overall you do need to expect the Q factor to be wider on spin bikes (except for Spinner) than that on outdoor bikes because of the manufacture and design to accommodate the functionality as well as keep the bike stable while you are riding your heart out.
But there is a choice that can be made in the Q factor width to get the narrowest distance that is right for you and you goals. But do expect to pay more than the more affordable bikes. You can get them at around $400 but you won’t get any of the premium features such as magnetic resistance, belt drive or console.
If you are using the bike for more casual exercise you are not likely to be as concerned with the Q factor as you are other factors but if you are expecting to be using your bike a lot it is worth investigating and getting the Q factor that is closer to your outdoor bike for the more biomechanical fit for more efficient workouts with less chance of knee injury.
Filed under: Buying Advice
Like this post? Subscribe to my RSS feed and get loads more!